Payment providers for online shops compared: which one is right for you?

😎 Price promotion
10% discount on all Trackboxx annual subscriptions with the code: tb10action
Table of contents

If you run an online shop, one thing matters above all: customers must be able to pay quickly, securely and conveniently . That is the role of a payment service provider (PSP), sometimes referred to as a payment service provider (PSP) or payment gateway.

This guide compares the main options, explains their differences and highlights the criteria that matter when choosing a provider.

Why does an online shop need a payment provider?

Payment providers handle essential parts of the transaction infrastructure, including:

  • Accepting card payments
  • Adding methods such as PayPal and Klarna
  • Screening transactions for potential fraud
  • Processing refunds
  • Supporting compliance with standards such as PCI DSS

In short, they remove much of the technical and operational complexity involved in taking payments.

Popular payment providers at a glance

These are some of the best-known options for online retailers:

ProviderPayment methodsIndicative fees*Ideal forKey features
StripeCredit card, Apple Pay, Google Pay1.4-2.9 % + € 0.25Modern shops and start-upsDeveloper-friendly with strong APIs
PayPalPayPal account, direct debit, credit card2.49-2.99 % + fixed amountBroad recognition across many marketsFamiliar to customers and quick to introduce
KlarnaPay later and instalments1.99-2.99 % + € 0.35Higher-priced productsKlarna assumes eligible credit risk for pay-later purchases
MollieMany (incl. Sofort, Giropay, Apple Pay)from 1.8 % + € 0.25Flexible and internationalStraightforward integration and a broad range of methods
Shopify PaymentsCredit cards, Klarna, Apple PayComparable to Stripe and built inShopify shopsNative integration can avoid Shopify's additional third-party transaction fee

*Fees vary by country, payment method, volume and contract. Check current provider pricing before deciding.

What should you consider?

Focus on the criteria that affect your customers and your margins:

  • Audience and payment preferences: Preferences differ by audience and market. Mobile wallets may matter for some groups, while invoice payments remain important in parts of Europe.
  • International coverage: Will you need additional currencies or local payment methods outside Germany?
  • Platform integration: Does the provider integrate reliably with Shopify, WooCommerce or Shopware?
  • Customer experience: A fast, trustworthy checkout can reduce abandonment and improve conversion.

Conclusion

There is no single best payment provider — only the best fit for your shop. Many retailers combine providers, such as Stripe plus PayPal, to cover the payment methods their customers expect.

Expert in web development & online marketing with over 15 years of experience.
Developer & CEO of Trackboxx – the Google Analytics alternative.

This might also interest you.

😎 Price promotion

10% off all annual subscriptions of Trackboxx with the code: